Skip to main content

ATTENTION: This site is no longer active but remains as an archive.

Iraq Veterans Against the War has become About Face: Veterans Against the War. About Face can be found at aboutfaceveterans.org

Iraq Veterans Against the War

Join IVAW

Donate to IVAW

  • About
    • Founding of IVAW
    • Mission, Values, and Vision
    • War in Afghanistan
    • Why We Are against the Wars
    • Resolutions
    • IVAW Timeline
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Committee
    • Staff
  • Events
  • Campaigns
    • Operation Recovery
    • Winter Soldier
      • Breakdown of the Military
      • Civilian Testimony
      • Corporate Pillaging
      • Cost of War at Home
      • Crisis in Veterans Healthcare
      • Future of GI Resistance
      • Gender and Sexuality
      • Legacy of GI Resistance
      • Racism and War
      • Response to DoD
      • Rules of Engagement
      • Press Coverage
      • Press Releases
    • Right to Heal
  • Members
  • Resources
    • AWOL
    • Active Duty
    • Conscientious Objector
    • Depleted Uranium
    • History of Resistance
    • IRR Reactivation
    • Lariam
    • PTSD
    • Profiles of Resisters
    • Resources for Veterans
    • Stop Loss
    • Women's Resources
    • Mesothelioma
  • Press
  • Contact
    • Press
    • Speaker Request

Premeditated

published by Bryan Reinholdt on 03/15/12 1:27am
Posted to: 
Board

For an act to be premeditated it has to be planned. In the United States we hear about premeditated murder and in some states this has been defined as mere seconds before the criminal act. Our reasoning for going to war with Iraq and Afghanistan was the premeditated plans of terrorists among other things that seemed to fail evidential  scrutiny. On September 12, 2001 the United States government decided to act in self-defense to those countries it deemed guilty of harboring terrorists. Iraq was the only country to endorse the September 11, 2001 attacks saying it was a “lesson for all tyrants and oppressors.” When violent actions aren’t premeditated they are classified as self-defense which is the legal justification for killing in situations that would otherwise be deemed murder. In this case, the act is called "justifiable murder." Are these wars premeditated murders or justifiable murders? The debate over the wars/occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan can be summed up in an analysis and comparison of premeditated acts and self-defense. In the recent killings of 16 Afghan women and children in Panjwaii district of Kandahar province by, allegedly, one rogue staff sergeant, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said, "War is hell. These kind of events and incidents are going to take place. They've taken place in any war. They're terrible events. This is not the first of those events, and they probably won't be the last." If we can place the Defense Secretary’s comments in the larger context of global war, we are all simultaneously acting in self-defense for what we believe is just cause for the enemy's premeditated murder. Chicken and the egg, but this is more than theory, it is about human lives. If we know, like Panetta states, that these kinds of atrocities are going to happen, how are we preventing them? We went into Iraq and Afghanistan with the premeditated intent to kill. Whether soldiers are told to engage in violent actions that amount to murder or justifiable murder against an enemy, this is the tightrope that Panetta seems to be walking on. Reports suggest that all safeguards were in place to thwart premeditated actions of this kind. Yet, soldiers exposed to traumatic experiences (PTSd, MST, and TBI) are repeatedly treated as if their experiences are justifiable while the soldiers themselves deal with the trauma as if they are premeditated murders. The trauma is mounting within each soldier and the nation collectively. A draw down in troops from Iraq and Afghanistan doesn’t mean the war is over. It continues in the minds of veterans. IVAW’s Operation Recovery campaign seeks to support service members standing up for their right to heal, to expose those responsible for deploying traumatized troops, to demand that those who deploy traumatized troops end their inhumane practice, and end these wars by winning our Right to Heal. Support our troops. Support Operation Recovery.  

IVAW Admin's picture

No place to go but up...

As we launch this new website and get ready to head into our first independent convention for Iraq Veterans Against the War, I hope that we can band together and overcome the adversity that we have experienced over the...
IVAW Admin's picture

New chapter and group pages!

Welcome to the new chapter and group page's. Because these pages are so new many do not even have their members added yet. If you know an IVAW member who should be listed on this page please email webmaster@ivaw.org or let...

Pages

  • « First
  • ‹ Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

Supporter Newsletter!

Donations

Make a single donation or become an IVAW sustainer by making your donation a recurring one. Please consider making your generous gift right now.
Donate Online Today!

Speaker Request

Please be advised that we get many speaker requests, but regret that we are sometimes unable to fill them.
Speaker Request

Joining IVAW

Iraq Veterans Against the War is open to Active Duty, National Guard and Reservists who have served since 09/11/2001.
Join IVAW

Navigation

  • About
  • Events
  • Campaigns
  • Committees
  • Chapters
  • Members
  • Resources
  • Contact